Save big on your family healthcare expenses. Become a myUpchar plus member only at Rs. 99 -

Since COVID-19 has appeared in the flu season and has a lot of similarities to influenza, it is constantly being compared to the flu virus. Is it as bad as the flu? Does it spread as quickly? How do you know if you have flu or COVID-19?, remain some of the most common questions.

To put this into context, influenza was responsible for causing a pandemic in 1919-20 affecting around 500 million people in the world (about 1/3rd of the world’s population at the time). Quite obviously, everyone is concerned about how grave this pandemic is.

For starters, it is important to know that both these respiratory diseases are caused by different viruses. The causative agent of COVID-19 is SARS-COV-2 and that of flu is influenza virus.

Also, experts all over the world have found some common differences and similarities between the two conditions.

Let’s find out more about them.

  1. Similarities between COVID-19 and flu
  2. Differences between COVID-19 and flu
  3. Doctors for How to tell the difference between COVID-19 symptoms and flu

Both COVID-19 and flu affect the respiratory tract and cause symptoms including fever, cough and fatigue

Both the conditions spread through coughing, sneezing or coming in close contact with contaminated surfaces (fomites) or the affected person and can be controlled by following good hygienic practices, wearing masks and testing all suspected cases for the presence of the infection

Read more: What is social distancing

The following are the differences between COVID-19 and flu:

Symptoms

COVID-19 may have some symptoms similar to flu however, there are some telltale differences between the two conditions. For starters, difficulty breathing is a common sign of COVID-19 but it happens less commonly in influenza. 

The Kansas Department of Health and Environment, USA, lists the following differences between COVID-19 and flu symptoms:

Symptom COVID-19 Flu
Cough Common Common but can be more severe at times
Sore throat Rarely Common
Runny nose Rarely Less common
Diarrhoea Less common Occurs sometimes only in children
Fatigue Less common Common and severe
Exhaustion Seen in some cases but develops gradually Absent
Headache Less common Intense headache
Body pain Less common Common and intense
Fever About 100 degree Celsius and is common About 100 to 102 degree Celsius and usually stays for 3 to 4 days 
Sneezing Rarely Sometimes
Shortness of breath Seen in severe infections Rarely seen

After exposure to the virus, it takes about 14 days for the signs of COVID-19 to appear and they do so gradually. On the other hand, the symptoms of influenza develop abruptly - within one to four days of exposure to the virus.

Transmission

The speed of transmission is much higher for Influenza virus than for COVID-19. According to the World Health Organisation (WHO), new cases arise within 3 days for the former and within 5 to 6 days for the latter.

A person with flu may pass the virus even before they show symptoms - in the incubation period. COVID-19 patients do spread the virus about a day or two before the onset of symptoms, but this shedding is not considered a major mediator of the transmission of the disease so far. 

About 80% of COVID-19 infections are either mild or asymptomatic which are being considered the major source of transmission of the disease right now. A recent study done at the University of Texas at Austin says that about 1 in 10 cases of COVID-19 are spread by asymptomatic people. 

According to the John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, about 50% cases of influenza are asymptomatic. This is due to the presence of partial immunity from a previous infection in a person. Partial immunity means the person has enough immunity to avoid severe and critical infection but he/she can still get the disease. These asymptomatic people also shed the virus but at a much lower rate than symptomatic people.

However, the R0 (reproductive number) for influenza pandemic was 1.80 (somewhere between 1.47 to 2.27), while the R0 for COVID-19 is between 1.5 to 3.5.

Reproductive number or R0 for a disease shows how many people a single infected person is likely to infect during his/her infectious period. This number is used to quantify the possible intensity of an epidemic or a pandemic.

At-risk people

Children are most at risk for influenza and are the major drivers of the infection as per the WHO. However, from the current data, COVID-19 infections remain mild or asymptomatic in children. Infants do get more severe infections than those above the age of 5. Also, reports from China show that children are getting COVID-19 from adults rather than the other way round as is seen in influenza. 

Both COVID-19 and influenza cause severe infections in the elderly, pregnant women, and immunocompromised people. 

Severe illness and mortality rate

Only 5% of cases of COVID-19 are severe and critical infections, however, the number is still much higher than that of influenza. 

Currently, the mortality rate of COVID-19 is suggested to be around 3 to 4%, the rate is 0.1% for seasonal influenza. Again, this rate is determined by a lot of factors including the age, health, quality of healthcare and ease of access to the treatment.

Vaccines and treatment

Since COVID-19 is a new disease, there is no vaccine for it so far. Those with mild infections are told to self-quarantine and are given antipyretics or other medications to control the symptoms. In severe cases, oxygen therapy and antiviral drugs are given to prevent compilations. The patients are constantly monitored in a hospital.

Influenza vaccines are developed each year depending on which strain of the virus is most prevalent in the given time. The World Health Organisation recommends that the elderly people, pregnant women and children should get the flu shot every year before the flu season begins.

Seasonal flu is treated with antiviral drugs along with antipyretics and anti-inflammatory medications for symptomatic management.

In both the conditions, the patient is asked to rest and keep up their fluid intake.

Dr. Neha Gupta

Dr. Neha Gupta

Infectious Disease
16 Years of Experience

Dr. Lalit Shishara

Dr. Lalit Shishara

Infectious Disease
8 Years of Experience

Dr. Alok Mishra

Dr. Alok Mishra

Infectious Disease
5 Years of Experience

Dr. Amisha Mirchandani

Dr. Amisha Mirchandani

Infectious Disease
8 Years of Experience

Medicine NamePack SizePrice (Rs.)
AlzumabAlzumab Injection6995.16
AnovateANOVATE OINTMENT 20GM90.0
Pilo GoPilo GO Cream67.5
Proctosedyl BdPROCTOSEDYL BD CREAM 15GM66.3
ProctosedylPROCTOSEDYL 10GM OINTMENT 10GM63.9
RemdesivirRemdesivir Injection15000.0
Fabi FluFabi Flu 200 Tablet1292.0
CoviforCovifor Injection5400.0
और पढ़ें ...

References

  1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [internet]. Atlanta (GA): US Department of Health and Human Services; 1918 Pandemic (H1N1 virus)
  2. Kansas Department of Health and Environment [Internet]. Topeka. Kansas. US; Coronavirus vs. Cold vs. Flu vs. Allergies.
  3. Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health [Internet]. Johns Hopkins Medicine. The Johns Hopkins University, The Johns Hopkins Hospital, and Johns Hopkins Health System; Do Public Health and Infection Control Measures Work to Prevent the Spread of Flu?
  4. Du Zhanwei, et al. Serial Interval of COVID-19 among Publicly Reported Confirmed Cases. Emerg Infect Dis. 2020; 26(6).
  5. Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy: University of Minnesota [Internet]. Minneapolis. Minnesota. US; Data suggest nCoV more infectious than 1918 flu, but what does that mean?
  6. Michigan Medicine: University of Michigan [internet]. US; How Scientists Quantify the Intensity of an Outbreak Like COVID-19
  7. Michigan School of Public Health [Internet] University of Michigan. US; R0: How Scientists Quantify the Intensity of an Outbreak Like Coronavirus and Its Pandemic Potential.
  8. World Health Organization [Internet]. Geneva (SUI): World Health Organization; Q&A: Similarities and differences – COVID-19 and influenza
ऐप पर पढ़ें